TWN Info Service on Biosafety
16 August 2022
Third World Network
www.twn.my
Dear Friends and Colleagues
Changes in ‘Keystone Genes’ May Disrupt Entire Ecosystems
A recent study (Item 1) highlights how changes in single genes (called ‘keystone genes’) can impact food webs and ecosystems. Researchers separated out and planted different genetic variants (alleles) of the genetic model organism Arabidopsis thaliana – which would all exist together in natural populations. They tested the effect of three plant defense genes on the persistence of an insect food web and found that a single allele at a single gene promoted coexistence by increasing plant growth rate, which in turn increased the intrinsic growth rates of species across multiple trophic levels. They found that even a reduction in the diversity of a single gene caused species interacting with the plants to become extinct.
These findings are highly relevant to the discussion on the risks of new GE techniques. Natural populations mostly have a whole range of the different gene variants which can help to stabilize the ecosystems. However, CRISPR/Cas applications change all the variants (alleles) of a gene within a population at the same time and in the same way, or completely block the gene functions respectively. The study shows that changes in one single ‘keystone gene’ can have far-reaching consequences for ecosystems: if corresponding genes are made uniform, i.e. the frequency of the abundance of different variants is reduced, this can have a destabilizing effect. Against this backdrop, organisms derived from new GE without mandatory risk assessment should not be approved. (Item 2)
With best wishes,
Third World Network
__________________________________________________________________________
Item 1
A KEYSTONE GENE UNDERLIES THE PERSISTENCE OF AN EXPERIMENTAL FOOD WEB
Matthew A. Barbour, Daniel J. Kliebenstein, & Jordi Bascompte
SCIENCE, Vol 376, Issue 6588, pp. 70-73
DOI: 10.1126/science.abf2232
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abf2232
31 March 2022
Abstract
Genes encode information that determines an organism’s fitness. Yet we know little about whether genes of one species influence the persistence of interacting species in an ecological community. Here, we experimentally tested the effect of three plant defense genes on the persistence of an insect food web and found that a single allele at a single gene promoted coexistence by increasing plant growth rate, which in turn increased the intrinsic growth rates of species across multiple trophic levels. Our discovery of a “keystone gene” illustrates the need to bridge between biological scales, from genes to ecosystems, to understand community persistence.
———————————————————————————————————————–
Item 2
CHANGES IN SINGLE GENES MAY THREATEN WHOLE ECOSYSTEMS
Testbiotech
https://www.testbiotech.org/en/news/changes-single-genes-may-threaten-whole-ecosystems
25 May 2022
Study sheds new light on the risks of New GE
A recent study has highlighted how changes in single genes can impact food webs and ecosystems. In the study, the researchers separated out and planted different genetic variants (alleles) of the genetic model organism Arabidopsis thaliana – which would all exist together in natural populations. The outcome was surprising: even a reduction in the diversity of a single gene caused species interacting with the plants to become extinct. The researchers therefore refer to such genes as ‘keystone genes’.
The researchers were able to show that the plants produced more or lesser amounts of specific natural substances (glucosinulates) depending on the particular gene and variant under investigation. The research paper focused on the impact of the different gene variants on the occurrence of aphids and beneficial insects (parasitoid wasps) which parasitise the aphids. Under the experimental conditions of the trials, there was a clear tendency: It was found that the reduction in genetic diversity was fostering destabilization of the food webs, the number of insects was often reduced or the investigated species became extinct. With one of the genetic variants, however, there was a strong increase in number of aphids and wasps, which also may indicate a potential disturbance of the ecosystems.
Organisms interact either directly or indirectly within ecosystems, thus creating complex food webs. Some species have a proportionately much higher influence on biodiversity within ecosystems and are, therefore, referred to as ‘keystone species’. In contrast, there has thus far been very little research into the impact of ‘keystone genes’ on biodiversity, because many of the complex interactions can only be partially investigated under experimental conditions. However, it remains a matter of uncertainty which genes under which conditions can be considered as ‘keystone genes’.
Testbiotech believes that these new findings are also highly relevant to the discussion on the risks of New GE (New Genetic Engineering). The published study shows that changes in one single ‘keystone gene’ can have far-reaching consequences for ecosystems: if corresponding genes are made uniform, i.e. the frequency of the abundance of different variants is reduced, this can have a destabilizing effect. Natural populations mostly have a whole range of the different gene variants which can help to stabilize the ecosystems. However, especially CRISPR/Cas applications can be used to change all the variants (alleles) of a gene within a population at the same time and in the same way, or completely block the gene functions respectively.
In this regard, the application of gene scissors is as such very much more efficient than conventional breeding. If the genetically engineered plants are released into the environment, their negative impacts can go far beyond what might otherwise be expected. Such effects may also be caused as a consequence of unintended genetic changes due to processes applied in New GE. Against this backdrop, Testbiotech is warning against the approval of organisms derived from New GE without mandatory risk assessment.
Contact:
Christoph Then, info@testbiotech.de, Tel +49 15154638040